The reasons for Vietnam’s glacial paced merger & acquisition (M&A) activity are many and rooted in multiple areas, including lengthy barriers and hurdles to development (read further details in this article), which naturally impact a project’s potential for acquisition. These include:
- Covid-19: Many ongoing M&A transactions have stalled or have been cancelled because of the pandemic, forcing Vietnamese project owners to adjust their strategies.
- Fair development premiums and financial feasibility: Due to the described tedious, costly and risky development process, developers require higher development premiums that most investors consider reasonable at the presented level of return and risk – a situation that also worsened through Covid-19 resulting in increased development period and costs for many developers. For projects that have been developed under the FIT phase 1 and could not reach COD by June 2019, the mismatch from the FIT phase 2 tariff or other prospective mechanisms is especially pronounced.
- Regulatory uncertainty: While the regulatory uncertainties experienced so far in Vietnam's solar sector mostly impacted developers, there is always a risk that governments apply retroactive changes to past programs when the costs are perceived as too high, as seen for example in Spain in 2015, with the introduction of a punitive solar tax or in Bulgaria in 2011, which introduced a sudden cut in tariffs.
- Model PPA and bankability: As it is for developers, this risk is adversely affecting investment decisions due to unresolved bankability concerns.
- Limited access to non-recourse financing: As it is for developers, the financing landscape is still lacking large-scale involvement of the international project financing community, with some large projects, mostly in co-financing constructs with ADB, taking the lead.
- Environment and social (E&S) concerns: Some renewable energy projects (especially in hydropower) are lacking required documentation and due diligence on E&S aspects, which present red flags to institutional investors and lenders.
- Lack of standardized M&A processes: Clear and standardized M&A processes and related documentation e.g., teaser, investment memo, financial models, structured data room with English documents etc., are yet to be established in Vietnam as most sellers lack experience and gathering of information is arduous.
- Curtailment: The significant curtailment of solar power plants, especially in the Southern and Central regions, partially curtailing some projects > 50%, is an ongoing reason for concern. While the Vietnamese government has announced the expansion of the transmission line network as a priority, it remains a lengthy task to realize and – in combination with the model PPA and its bankability concerns – poses a significant financial risk to project investors and lenders.
Table 1: Examples of key M&A activities in the Vietnamese solar power landscape
|Buyer (Country)||Target project||Transaction details||Timing of acquisition||Project(s) capacity||Project locations|
|Super Energy (Thailand)||Loc Ninh Solar Power Plants 1–4||Acquisition of 70% of shares for USD 70M||March 2020||550 MW||Binh Phuoc|
|B. Grimm (Thailand)||Hoa Hoi Solar Power Plant||Acquisition of 80% of shares from Truong Thanh Viet Nam Group (TTVN) for USD 35.2M||August 2018||275 MW||Phu Yen|
|BC Container Glass (Thailand)||Xuan Tho 1&2 Solar Power Plants||Acquisition of 12.86% of shares for undisclosed amount||September 2020||99.2 MW||Phu Yen|
|Gulf Energy (Thailand)||TTCIZ-02 Solar Power Plant||Acquisition of additional 41% (increase to total 90%) for undisclosed amount||January 2019||50 MW||Tay Ninh|
|Begistics (Thailand)||GA Power Solar Park Cam Xuyen and GA Power Solar Park Huong Son||Acquisition of 40% of shares for undisclosed amount||July 2019||2 x 29 MW||Ha Tinh|
Why solar M&A in Vietnam is about to ramp up
Looking ahead, we can expect solar M&A activity to start gathering steam in the coming months, with investors beginning to assess risks from other perspectives instead of only focusing on the model PPA bankability concerns. This is because:
- Large supply of operational solar projects: 2,988.9 MW of ground-mounted solar projects will potentially reach COD by the end of 2020, further adding to existing operational solar assets out of which many will be up for acquisition. Unlike greenfield project acquisitions, for projects under development, which require consent of Vietnamese authorities and are difficult to execute, brownfield acquisitions of operational plants are far easier from a legal point of view and also reduce the risk of forecasting generation as real data already exists.
- EVN’s positive credit rating: In June 2018, Fitch assigned its first and positive credit rating of “BB” to EVN, which in April 2020 was confirmed with a stable outlook at the same level as the Vietnam sovereign rating. Therefore, besides the model PPA, there is a high likelihood of EVN honoring payments under the PPA.
- Vietnam’s reliance on foreign direct investment: Vietnam relies heavily on foreign direct investment (FDI) to grow its economy and is one of the most open economies in the world. Any negative headlines in the power sector would likely damage this reputation and be against Vietnam’s own strategic interests of further attracting FDI in the sector that urgently requires more foreign capital.
- Growing appetite by foreign lenders: As shown, the first large projects have received loans from international financing institutions – a trend likely to continue as there seems to be a growing appetite to finance such projects and lenders are starting to get familiar with assessing and mitigating underlying risks.
- Projected scarcity of electricity in Vietnam: Vietnam will face severe power shortages from 2021 onwards when electricity demand will outpace the construction of new generation capacity. Again, Vietnam can hardly afford to scare off foreign investors, who are much needed for investing in new generation capacity and expanding the still underdeveloped transmission line system.
- Attractive electricity tariffs: Compared to other solar projects in the regions and potential future tariffs in Vietnam under announced competitive selection processes, the tariffs awarded under both FIT phases are high, allowing for relatively high returns.
- Outlook of competitive selection process: The announced competitive selection process will likely make it more difficult for developers looking to sell projects post completion to participate in, leaving the market to large IPPs that would hold onto these assets for a long period of time and effectively reduce numbers of projects up for acquisition.
For these reasons, the M&A market for solar projects in Vietnam offers many opportunities, but time is of the essence to secure the best projects now coming online.
This is an excerpt from a larger article on Vietnam’s solar market, you can read it here”
About the author
Moritz Sticher is senior advisor, Vietnam, for Apricum – The Cleantech Advisory, a Berlin-based, globally active transaction advisory and strategy consulting firm specialized in the cleantech and renewable energy space. An experienced international solar project developer with expertise in realizing all aspects of C&I and utility-scale solar projects – from strategy and business plan development through to EPC, O&M, and project financing, Moritz joined the team this year. He has significant knowledge and experience in Southeast Asian markets, particularly in Thailand, Vietnam, Cambodia, Indonesia, Singapore, and the Philippines.
The views and opinions expressed in this article are the author’s own, and do not necessarily reflect those held by pv magazine.
This content is protected by copyright and may not be reused. If you want to cooperate with us and would like to reuse some of our content, please contact: email@example.com.