From pv magazine Spain
Redeia, the parent company of REE, held a press conference this week in Madrid to present its report on the April 28 power outage that left millions without electricity across Spain. REE President Beatriz Corredor denied that REE was responsible, mere hours after the Spanish government blamed the incident on poor planning by the system operator.
REE attributed the start of the blackout to a “malfunction” at a PV plant in Badajoz. It declined to reveal further details due to “confidentiality” reasons. The plant allegedly caused a “forced frequency oscillation.”
REE General Director of Operations Concha Sánchez said the incident began at 12:03 p.m. (CEST), when the system “began to experience a forced frequency oscillation” that triggered “a drop in voltage” and a “very significant” fluctuation lasting nearly five minutes. She said it required immediate action due to the “dangerous” conditions. REE changed the interconnection with France from alternating current operation to a fixed setpoint, in agreement with French system operator RTE.
Later, REE said it observed a “significant” disturbance on a power line in Badajoz and reduced the electricity exchange with Portugal. At 12:16 p.m., the oscillation recurred, it said. It originated at a “photovoltaic plant that we will call A in the province of Badajoz,” which is “connected to the transmission grid.” Sánchez said the oscillation “unequivocally” resulted from malfunctioning internal controls at the plant, an issue “that must be clarified by the owner.”
The anomalous fluctuations led to the disconnection of 700 MW of generation, mainly from small facilities outside REE's visibility, including self-consumption plants.
Subsequently, export flows “reduced,” voltages kept rising, and a substation in Granada experienced a generation trip. Disconnections continued, including another 582 MW in Badajoz. When the transmission grid had lost over 2,000 MW and “a considerable volume” on distribution networks, the system could no longer maintain voltage levels.
Sánchez said that until that point “we cannot speak of overvoltages,” noting that voltage levels remained within regulatory limits. She also stated that some generators failed to comply with voltage control obligations. “They must provide this service,” she said. According to REE simulations, the blackout could have been avoided if generators had delivered the required voltage control, since “sufficient” capacity was available. “It's a different matter” whether the companies obligated to provide the service actually did so, she added.
In a new report this week, Spain’s Ecological Transition Ministry identified three main causes for the system failure: insufficient voltage control capacity, fluctuations caused by grid constraints, and generation disconnections it described as “apparently improper.” The ministry concluded that voltage went unregulated due to poor planning by the system operator, and several generators failed to meet their obligations.
This content is protected by copyright and may not be reused. If you want to cooperate with us and would like to reuse some of our content, please contact: editors@pv-magazine.com.
I claim no expertise on this, but in general one would expect malfunctions to be be better contained, and protective systems to be available, at several levels. The grid in Spain, as in other countries, has evolved rapidly into one characterised by large numbers of technically and economically independent generators. My modest 4kw solar system is a tiny part of the supply network. I assume it has been properly connected but have no way of knowing, and have to rely on the reputations of the installer and the manufacturers of the equipment. The grid operator, in this case REE, can lay down standards for the way these generators connect to the grid but cannot guarantee their implementation. Mistakes are bound to be made. When this happens, the grid operator should be able to contain and limit the damage with resources under its direct control. In the recent incident, the damage spread to half the country and most of Portugal. REE can’t escape all responsibility. The same holds for the incident at Heathrow in London, where the fallout was local, but included the entire airport.